Best Insoles for Running Shoes

Best Insoles for Running Shoes

Every running shoe arrives with a thin foam sockliner that costs the brand almost nothing. It covers the stitching, adds a whisper of cushioning, and for many runners it is the weakest part of an otherwise excellent shoe.

I am Muhammad, editor of RunningShoes.fit, and this is the only accessory guide in our current series: the best insoles for running shoes, when they genuinely help, and when they are money spent fixing the wrong problem. An insole can tune a good shoe. It cannot rescue a bad one.

When an insole genuinely helps

Your stock insoles are worn out

Stock liners usually die long before the midsole does.

How to tell the liner is dead

Pull the liner out and look at it, because the signs are easy to miss while it sits inside the shoe. A dead liner stays compressed where the heel and the ball of the foot sit, instead of springing back when you press it, and the heel cup often collapses sideways so the foot slides instead of sitting centred. Cracking or flaking on the top surface and a smell that survives airing are later signs that the foam has broken down. If the liner looks flat but the midsole still springs back under your thumb, a replacement liner is the cheap fix. If the midsole is creased and flat too, the shoe is finished and no liner will save it.

If your shoes feel harsh even though the foam still springs back, or the liner has compressed into a foot shaped pancake, a quality replacement restores the step in feel for a fraction of the cost of new shoes.

You have a mild, recurring ache

A sore arch at the end of long runs, or heels that feel bruised on back to back days, often respond well to structured support. The insole holds your foot in a better position inside a shoe that otherwise fits, which is a very different job from correcting a serious gait problem.

When it is a waste of money

If the shoe is the wrong size, the wrong shape, or worn out in the midsole, no insole fixes that. A thick insert in a tight shoe makes fit worse, and a supportive insert in a shoe that already guides your stride can double up support until every step feels argued with. Buy the right shoe first, then tune it.

The best insoles for running shoes

Best structured support: Superfeet Run Comfort

The Superfeet Run Comfort, now sold as Run Support, is the insole most runners mean when they say orthotic style support. A carbon fibre stabiliser cap sits under the heel and arch, topped with two layers of rebound foam, so your foot gets a firm, shaped platform rather than a soft pad.

It suits runners with medium to high arches and shoes with enough volume to spare, and Superfeet rates its insoles for up to twelve months or 500 miles of use.

The name has changed since older reviews were written: Superfeet now sells this line as Run Support, in low, medium, and high arch versions, at $59.99 a pair. The carbon fibre stabiliser cap under the heel and arch is still the heart of it, now topped with Aerospring rebound foam, and Superfeet rates the insole for up to twelve months or 500 miles of use. Pick the arch version by the shape of your foot, not by the shoe: a low arch in a high arch insole will press, and a high arch in a low arch insole will feel like nothing is there. An insole also lifts the foot slightly, so read our guide to heel drop explained before you judge the fit.

The deep heel cup also helps if your heel wanders inside looser trainers, a problem we cover in our guide on how running shoes should fit.

Best flexible support: Currex RunPro

The Currex RunPro takes the opposite approach: flexible, dynamic support that moves with your foot instead of holding it. It comes in three arch profiles, low, medium, and high, so you match the insole to your arch rather than forcing your arch to match the insole.

At about $60 it is the priciest pick here, but it is also the least intrusive in lower volume shoes, and the Fleet Feet guide to choosing a Currex insole explains the profile system clearly.

At $59.95 the RunPro costs about the same as the Superfeet, but the feel is different: a flexible arch bridge that bends and returns as the foot moves, instead of a rigid shell that holds the foot in one shape. That is why runners who felt a firm insole as a lump under the arch often get on better with the RunPro, and why it fits lower volume shoes that a thick structured insole would crowd. Match the profile honestly: the wrong one feels either absent or intrusive within the first easy run.

Choose it if firm Superfeet style support has ever felt like a lump under your arch.

Best for sore arches: PowerStep Pinnacle

The PowerStep Pinnacle is the podiatry office favourite: a firm supportive shell with a cushioned top layer, sold at a friendlier price than the other two. It is the one most often recommended for mild arch pain and early plantar fascia grumbles, because it supports without feeling like a cast.

It is thicker than the RunPro, so it needs a roomy shoe, and runners with ongoing heel pain should read the independent roundup at Running Gear Lab’s best insoles for running alongside our guide to the best running shoes for plantar fasciitis before spending anything.

InsoleSupport styleBest for
Superfeet Run ComfortFirm, structuredHigh arches, heel control
Currex RunProFlexible, dynamicLow volume shoes, natural feel
PowerStep PinnacleFirm shell, cushioned topMild arch pain, value

How to fit an insole properly

The PowerStep Pinnacle sells for about $54.95, which makes it the cheapest of the three, and it is the over the counter version of the ProTech orthotic sold through podiatrists, so the shape has clinical roots rather than being a generic foam pad. The firm shell with a cushioned top layer is the reason it suits mild arch pain: it holds the arch up without the hard edge that makes some structured insoles feel like a cast. If heel pain keeps returning, get the shoe checked first, because an insole cannot fix a collapsed heel counter, and our guide to best running shoes for Achilles tendon pain explains when the shoe, not the insole, needs to change.

Always remove the stock liner first. An aftermarket insole stacked on top of the original raises your foot, tightens the fit, and changes how the shoe was designed to hold you, which is how a good insole gets blamed for a bad result.

Trim to the shape of the old liner, then walk around the house before you run. Expect a short adjustment period of a few easy runs, the same patience we recommend in our guide on how to break in new running shoes, because your feet need time to trust the new shape under them.

If the ache you are chasing sits under the arch itself, compare your symptoms with our guide to the best running shoes for arch pain before assuming an insert is the answer. Sometimes the shoe category, not the liner, is the problem.

Insoles vs a better shoe

Do the maths honestly.

A $60 insole rated for 500 miles costs about 12 cents a mile, which is cheap insurance inside a healthy shoe, but the same $60 inside a shoe with 400 miles on it buys a tuned version of a dying shoe. Run the numbers both ways: insole plus remaining shoe life against a fresh pair. Fit is the other half of the maths, because an insole adds volume and can make a snug shoe tighter across the toes or looser at the heel, so after fitting one, relace with a heel lock and walk first: our guide to how to lace running shoes shows the pattern that stops heel slip without squeezing the forefoot.

A $60 insole inside a $150 shoe with 400 miles on it buys you a tuned version of a dying shoe, while the same money towards a fresh pair resets the midsole, the outsole, and the upper all at once.

Insoles win when the shoe is healthy and the complaint is specific: a worn liner, a mild arch ache, a heel that slips. Shoes win when the platform itself is wrong, and if pain keeps returning, a clinician beats both, as our best shoes for flat feet guide explains for runners whose arches need more than an insert can give.

Fit check, before any of the above: an insole adds volume. If your shoes were already snug across the toes, a thick structured insert will make them smaller inside, so insoles pair best with shoes that have a little room to give, or with the stock liner removed and a thinner profile chosen.

How to choose between the three

Match the insole to the complaint. If your heels wander and your arches feel unsupported in a roomy shoe, the firm structure of the Superfeet is the fix, and it is the closest thing here to a traditional orthotic.

If structured inserts have always felt like standing on a golf ball, start with the Currex. Its flexible support is gentler, it fits more shoes, and the three arch profiles mean you are fitting your foot rather than fighting a generic shape.

If money is tight and the complaint is a mild arch ache, the PowerStep Pinnacle is the honest first step. It costs less than a physio appointment, and if it does not settle the ache, that is useful information too: the problem was never the insole.

Whichever you choose, buy from a retailer with a real returns policy and judge it over two weeks of easy runs, not one excited outing. Insoles change how your foot is loaded, and feet vote slowly.

Watch: do you need running insoles?

This video walks through what an insole can and cannot do, and how to tell a worn stock liner from a real support problem. It mirrors the honest approach of this guide.

Frequently asked questions

Do running insoles actually help?

They help specific problems: worn stock liners, mild arch aches, and heels that move around inside the shoe. They do not fix a shoe that is the wrong size, the wrong shape, or worn out in the midsole, and they are not a treatment for ongoing injuries.

Should I remove the original insole before adding a new one?

Yes, always. Stacking an aftermarket insole on top of the stock liner raises your foot, tightens the fit, and changes how the shoe holds you. Take the original out, use it as the trimming template, and keep it in case you ever want to swap back.

How long do running insoles last?

Most quality insoles last about 500 miles or twelve months, whichever comes first. Structured models like the Superfeet hold their shape longest, while soft foam inserts compress sooner and should be replaced when the arch shape feels flat.

Can insoles help plantar fasciitis?

They can ease symptoms for some runners by supporting the arch and reducing strain, and the PowerStep Pinnacle is a common first step. Persistent heel pain needs proper assessment though, because insoles support the foot, they do not treat the injury itself.

Are expensive insoles worth it over cheap ones?

Usually, yes. Cheap drugstore inserts are mostly flat foam with a new smell, while the picks here have shaped support that survives hundreds of miles. The exception is simple cushioning: if you only want a fresher step in feel, a basic liner replacement does the job.

The bottom line

Insoles are a tuning tool, not a rescue service. The Superfeet Run Comfort adds structure, the Currex RunPro adds flexible support, and the PowerStep Pinnacle adds affordable arch help, but the rule comes first: tune the right shoe, never rescue the wrong one.

Start by checking the shoe itself against our roundup of the best running shoes to buy in 2026. If the shoe passes and the ache is small and specific, an insole is money well spent.

Medical disclaimer: this article is for general information only and is not medical advice. Insoles cannot replace a proper diagnosis, and if you have persistent foot pain, please see a qualified healthcare professional for an individual assessment and treatment plan.

Muhammad

Muhammad is a passionate runner and the editor of RunningShoes.fit. He spends his weekends logging miles on roads and trails, researching shoe technology, and comparing models side by side so readers can find the right fit without the guesswork. His guides focus on practical, real-world advice for runners of every level.

Leave a Reply