Before you spend money on another pair of shoes, spend two minutes on your laces. A surprising share of fit complaints, slipping heels, sore insteps, and black toenails, are lacing problems wearing a shoe problem’s clothes.
I am Muhammad, editor of RunningShoes.fit, and this guide shows how to lace running shoes for a better fit, one pattern per problem. Each technique below takes a minute to learn, costs nothing, and can be tested on your very next run.
Before you relace: the basics
Lacing fine tunes a shoe that already fits; it cannot rescue one that does not.
The fit test to run before you relace
Check three things first. Is there about a thumb’s width ahead of the longest toe, does the heel sit in the counter without lifting on stairs, and is there any pressure point when you stand still? If the answer to the first two is no, relacing will only move the problem, because a shoe that is too short will still jam toes on downhills and a shoe that is too long will still slip at the heel. Our full checklist in how running shoes should fit covers the three fit zones.
Then put your foot in properly. Kick your heel back into the heel cup, tap it on the floor, and only then start lacing from the bottom, snugging each pair of eyelets in turn so tension is even along the whole shoe.
Heel slip: the runner’s loop
If your heel lifts with every step, or your toes slide forward and jam the front of the shoe on downhills, the runner’s loop is the fix. It uses the extra top eyelet that most runners ignore, and the REI guide to lacing running shoes demonstrates the same technique.
- Lace normally, crisscrossing, until you reach the second eyelet from the top on each side.
- Instead of crossing, take each lace straight up into the top eyelet on its own side, forming a small loop.
- Cross the laces over and pass each end through the loop on the opposite side.
- Pull the ends up and outward to cinch the loops down around your ankle, then tie as usual.
The loop pulls your foot back and holds it there, locking the heel into the counter without crushing the midfoot.
The runner’s loop works because it changes where the tension goes. Instead of tightening the whole midfoot, the loops at the top pull the foot back and down into the heel counter, which stops the heel lifting and stops the toes sliding forward on downhills. That is why it helps black toenails as well as heel blisters: both come from the foot moving forward inside the shoe. To test it, lace the loop on one shoe only and walk down a slope, then compare the two sides. If the looped shoe holds and the other slips, the pattern is doing its job. If both still slip, the shoe is too long or too high in volume. Runners with a bunion should test the loop with a wider shoe too, and our guide to running shoes for bunions covers toe boxes that pair well with it.
Most runners feel the difference within the first kilometre, and it is the single most useful lacing change you can make, especially in new shoes while they settle, as our guide on how to break in new running shoes also recommends.Top of foot pain: window lacing
A hot spot or ache across the top of the foot, right where a lace crossing sits, usually means pressure on a tendon or a small bone spur. Window lacing builds a gap in the lacing exactly over the sore spot.
- Unlace down to just below the painful spot.
- Run each lace straight up on its own side, skipping one pair of eyelets so no crossing presses on the sore area.
- Resume normal crisscross lacing above the gap, and tie off as usual.
The window trades a little midfoot security for relief, so pair it with the runner’s loop at the top if the heel starts to wander. If the pain is sharp, numb, or keeps returning in the same place, treat it as a fit problem rather than a lacing problem.
Black toenails: diagonal lacing
Bruised and blackened toenails mean your toes are ramming the front of the shoe, usually because the foot slides forward or the big toe gets pressed down by the lacing. Diagonal lacing lifts the toe box slightly over the big toe and gives it room.
- Start with one lace end at the bottom eyelet on the big toe side, and pull it diagonally straight to the top eyelet on the opposite side.
- Take the long remaining end and weave it across and up through every eyelet in turn, in a straight crisscross pattern.
- Finish with a runner’s loop at the top if your heel also slips.
Combine it with the basics: nails trimmed, socks that grip rather than slide, and enough length in the shoe. If toenails keep bruising on long runs despite all three, the shoe is too short or too shallow, and no lacing pattern will save it. Retail advice like the Road Runner Sports guide to preventing heel slippage makes the same point: lacing fixes movement, not size.
High arches: open lacing
A high arch often comes with a high instep, and standard crisscross lacing bridges straight over it, pressing down with every step. Open lacing uses straight vertical segments through the midfoot to spread that pressure out.
- Lace the first two or three eyelet pairs normally at the front of the shoe.
Open lacing works by spreading pressure across the instep instead of bridging over it. A high arch often comes with a high instep, so a normal crisscross presses down on the same spot with every step, and that pressure can cause a hot spot or numbness across the top of the foot. Straight vertical segments through the midfoot leave that area freer while the forefoot and ankle stay held. The trade off is a little less midfoot security, so finish with a runner’s loop at the top if the heel starts to wander. If the pain is sharp, numb, or returns in the same place run after run, treat it as a fit problem and check the shoe volume.
- Through the midfoot, run each lace straight up on its own side instead of crossing, for two or three eyelet pairs.
- Cross again at the top pairs and finish with a runner’s loop for security.
The forefoot and ankle stay held while the instep gets breathing room, which also helps runners whose feet swell noticeably on long runs. High arched runners comparing shoes as well as laces should look at our guide to the best running shoes for arch pain for models with the right support built in.
Small habits that make any lacing work better
Relace from scratch every few weeks.
Laces migrate as shoes age, and the change is gradual enough that most runners do not notice it. Tension ends up uneven, with one side tighter than the other, and the shoe starts to feel different even though nothing else changed. A full relace resets that drift: unlace completely, seat the heel back in the counter, then snug each pair of eyelets in turn from the bottom, keeping tension even along the whole shoe.
Laces migrate as shoes age, tension ends up uneven, and a full relace with even snugging from the bottom resets the fit more than runners expect.If your laces keep coming undone, finish with a surgeon’s knot: make the first overhand throw twice instead of once before forming the bow. It takes two seconds longer and holds all day, which is why REI teaches it alongside the techniques above.
Finally, lace for the foot you will have at kilometre fifteen, not the one you have at the door. Feet swell as you run, so a fit that feels perfect standing still and painfully tight later usually just needs the midfoot eyelets left one notch looser.
One change at a time
Resist the urge to combine patterns on day one.
One change at a time is the only way to learn what works. Change the lacing, run in it twice, and note the result before you change socks, insoles, or the shoe itself. If you stack three changes and the pain goes away, you will not know which one fixed it, and you will not know what to repeat in the next pair. Keep a one line note in your training log: pattern, problem, and result. That note is dull to write and useful six months later, when the same ache shows up in a different shoe. The same rule applies to fit: if a pattern helps for a week and then stops helping, the shoe may be wearing out, and our guide to how many miles running shoes last explains the wear signs to check first.
Change a single variable, run in it twice, and judge the result, because stacking a runner’s loop on top of window lacing and a new pair of socks leaves you with no idea which change actually helped.Keep notes if your feet are fussy. A line in your training log about which pattern fixed which problem is dull to write and wonderful to find six months later, when the same ache shows up in a different pair of shoes and you already own the answer.
And remember that lacing interacts with everything else: sock thickness, insole choice, and even how swollen your feet are at different times of day. The pattern that felt wrong on a cold morning sometimes feels perfect on a warm evening run, so give each experiment a fair chance before you abandon it.
When lacing is not the problem
Be honest about the limits. If your heel slips even with a runner’s loop, the shoe is too long or too high in volume, and if your toes feel cramped in every pattern, the shoe is too small or too narrow, full stop.
Wide feet in particular cannot be laced into a standard shoe, and runners in that position do far better in a proper wide model, like the ones in our guide to the best running shoes for wide feet. Lacing is fine tuning, not a rescue service.
Watch: lacing tips for running shoes
This REI video shows the runner’s loop and window lacing on a real shoe. Watch it once and you will be able to copy both patterns from memory.
Frequently asked questions
Does the runner’s loop really work?
Yes. It is the most effective lacing change most runners ever make, because it pulls the foot back into the heel counter and holds it there. Heel slip, heel blisters, and toes jamming forward on downhills all improve for most runners.
Should running shoe laces be tight or loose?
Snug, not tight. The midfoot should feel held without any numbness or tingling, and the forefoot should always have room to spread. If your feet tingle after ten minutes, loosen the lower eyelets first.
Why do my laces keep coming undone?
Usually the knot, not the lace. Finish with a surgeon’s knot by wrapping the first throw twice before making the bow, and check that you are tying a balanced reef style bow rather than a granny knot, which slowly works itself loose.
Can lacing fix shoes that are too big?
Only slightly. A runner’s loop and thicker socks can take up a small amount of extra volume, but a shoe that is a full size too long will keep causing problems. Fit comes first, and lacing only fine tunes it.
What is the best lacing for wide feet?
Open or gap lacing through the midfoot relieves pressure across a wide forefoot. If you still feel squeezed, the real answer is a wide fitting shoe, since lacing cannot create width the shoe does not have.
The bottom line
Four patterns cover almost every fit complaint a runner will ever have: the runner’s loop for heel slip, window lacing for a sore instep, diagonal lacing for black toenails, and open lacing for high arches. Try the one that matches your problem first, and always fix the fit before you replace the shoe.
Your next pair will fit better for everything you learn from lacing this one. That is the real win here: knowledge you keep long after these shoes are retired.

